J.J. Abrams’ Crime Drama Canceled by HBO Max After One Season Despite Strong Reviews

The crime drama Duster is officially done at HBO Max. Even though the show got strong reviews and was liked by many viewers, it just didn’t attract a big enough audience to stick around.

According to Entertainment Weekly, HBO Max decided not to bring the show back for a second season. It was one of the platform’s original series and the first reunion in 15 years for Lost star Josh Holloway and creator J.J. Abrams.

In a statement shared with EW, HBO Max said, “While HBO Max will not be moving forward with a second season of Duster, we are so grateful to have had the chance to work with the amazingly talented co-creators J.J. Abrams and LaToya Morgan, and our partners at Bad Robot and Warner Bros. Television. We are tremendously proud of this series led by Josh Holloway and Rachel Hilson and we thank them along with our cast and crew for their incredible collaboration and partnership.”

Duster was co-created by Abrams and LaToya Morgan. Warner Bros. Television, which co-produced the series, also shared their appreciation for the team. They said, “J.J. Abrams and LaToya Morgan delivered a thrilling, multi-dimensional crime drama in Duster, with textured characters that took the audience back to the 1970s in a new and innovative way… we are incredibly proud of the show.”

The series followed FBI agent Nina Hayes, played by Rachel Hilson, who was the first Black woman agent in the Bureau. She teams up with getaway driver Jim Ellis, played by Holloway, to take down a dangerous crime boss. It had a gritty, 1970s vibe and aimed to mix old-school crime storytelling with a fresh feel.

The show had been in the works since 2021. In the meantime, Holloway and Abrams were both keeping busy with other projects. Holloway starred in shows like Colony, and Abrams worked on major movies like Star Wars: The Force Awakens and Star Trek Into Darkness.

In an interview earlier this year, Holloway shared how excited he was when Abrams pitched him the idea for the show. “This concept is phenomenal, he just opened the conversation with, ‘You’re a fixer for the mafia in 1972,'” he said. “And I was like, ‘Oh my God, my mind just blew up.’ There’s nothing like it on TV right now. It is like Pulp Fiction meets Starsky & Hutch.”

Despite solid reviews from critics and good word-of-mouth, the show didn’t get enough traction to justify more episodes. Streaming platforms often base renewal decisions on viewership numbers and subscriber interest, and Duster just didn’t pull in the crowd it needed.

This marks the end of a brief but ambitious project for both Holloway and Abrams. While it didn’t last long, Duster will still be remembered by fans who appreciated its bold style and storytelling.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments below!