Why Sam Wilson Isn’t MCU’s Captain America – And Why It’s Better That Way

The first trailer for ‘Captain America: Brave New World’ unveils action, Sam Wilson in full force, Thaddeus Ross as Red Hulk, Esposito’s mysterious villain, and the controversial inclusion of Sabra.

However, Sabra’s presence isn’t the only contentious issue. The main source of debate remains Sam Wilson inheriting the Captain America mantle in ‘Endgame.’ While some objections are grounded, others stem from misunderstanding.

In one trailer scene, Thunderbolt Ross tells Wilson, “You are not Steve Rogers,” and Wilson agrees. This truth sets the stage for the upcoming ‘Captain America’ installment to offer a fresh perspective on the iconic character.

Sam Wilson’s portrayal as Captain America diverges significantly from what MCU fans are accustomed to, and that’s a positive development for several reasons.

Critics of Wilson’s Captain America often overlook the fact that his story aligns with the comics, where he also inherits the mantle. ‘Endgame’ provided a fitting conclusion for Steve Rogers, offering closure to his arc. Therefore, the evolution of Falcon’s character in the MCU is not about political correctness but rather staying faithful to the source material, similar to how Shuri assumed the mantle in the comics after T’Challa’s passing.

Fans are understandably concerned because Wilson lacks the Super Soldier Serum, making him a regular human who faces an uphill battle against the formidable Red Hulk.

However, this situation also presents an intriguing opportunity, as noted by actor Anthony Mackie. In ‘Brave New World,’ the action will be more raw and realistic due to the heightened stakes. Behind the vibranium shield, there’s not a superhuman but a regular human, intensifying the risks involved. The possibility of Wilson facing mortal danger is significant. Despite these perils, he bravely throws himself into the fray because it’s his duty—he chose this path.

Wilson’s Captain America will be firmly rooted in reality, showcasing a less judgmental perspective compared to Steve Rogers. Rogers, shaped by propaganda and institutional influence, sometimes held views that didn’t accurately reflect the world.

Wilson, on the other hand, is disillusioned and possesses a modern outlook. He understands societal flaws and approaches them with a realistic mindset. His journey to assuming the mantle, independent of his race, underscores his struggles and determination. This makes Wilson’s Captain America exceptionally relatable and, in many respects, more noble.

However, returning to the criticism, one aspect I must agree with is that Falcon was already a well-established and beloved character among fans. It will be challenging to dissociate him from that identity, and I’m unsure if this criticism will ever fully dissipate. Joaquin Torres now takes on the mantle of Falcon, and I’m eager to see him in action, though it will be difficult to see him as THE Falcon.

While critics of the new Captain America raise valid points, many of their arguments fall short and lack logical consistency, especially when considering the source material.

What are your thoughts on this? Share in the comments below!