Rachel Brosnahan’s 10 Must-Watch Underrated Films

Rachel Brosnahan has become a household name, thanks to her standout role in ‘The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel’, but her film career is packed with hidden gems that deserve more attention. From gritty dramas to heartfelt comedies, she’s shown her range across genres, often stealing scenes even in smaller roles.

With her upcoming turn as Lois Lane in ‘Superman’ (2025), now’s the perfect time to dive into her lesser-known movies. We’ve rounded up ten films that highlight her talent and prove she’s more than just a TV star. These picks showcase her ability to bring depth and charm to every project.

The Unborn (2009)

Brosnahan kicked off her film career with a chilling role as Lisa in this horror thriller. She plays a teen caught up in a supernatural battle against an ancient evil spirit haunting a young woman.

Her screen time is brief, but she makes an impact with her raw energy. The film’s eerie vibe and fast pace make it a solid pick for horror fans looking for her early work.

The Truth About Average Guys (2009)

In this quirky comedy, Brosnahan shines as Molly, a friend navigating the chaos of a man’s wild plan to win over his crush. The movie’s humor and heart make it a fun, under-the-radar indie.

Her performance adds warmth to the story’s oddball charm. It’s a lighthearted watch that shows her knack for comedy even in her early roles.

Coming Up Roses (2011)

Brosnahan plays Lucy, a teen dealing with her mother’s struggles in this poignant drama. The story follows a former actress and her daughter as they face financial woes and emotional turmoil.

Her portrayal captures the angst and resilience of youth. This quiet film offers a touching look at family bonds, with Brosnahan’s performance grounding the emotional core.

Nor’easter (2012)

In this suspenseful drama, Brosnahan takes on the role of Abby, a young woman tied to a mysterious reunion on a small island. The story unravels secrets and tensions within a tight-knit community.

Her understated performance adds depth to the film’s moody atmosphere. It’s a slow-burn thriller that rewards patient viewers with its haunting narrative.

A New York Heartbeat (2013)

Brosnahan stars as Tamara, a sheltered teen who gets caught up with a fugitive gang leader in this 1950s-set crime drama. Her character’s innocence clashes with the gritty underworld, creating compelling tension.

She brings vulnerability and strength to the role, making it a standout. The film’s retro vibe and intense plot make it a hidden gem for crime fans.

Louder Than Bombs (2015)

Playing Erin, the ex-girlfriend of a grieving son, Brosnahan adds emotional weight to this family drama. The story explores a mother’s death and the secrets she left behind.

Her scenes are brief but pivotal, showcasing her ability to convey complex emotions. This introspective film is a must-see for its powerful performances and quiet intensity.

The Finest Hours (2016)

Brosnahan portrays Bea Hansen, a widow caught in a dramatic rescue mission in this disaster epic. The film follows a Coast Guard team battling a brutal storm to save stranded sailors.

Her role is small but memorable, adding heart to the high-stakes action. It’s a gripping watch that blends historical drama with thrilling heroics.

Burn Country (2016)

As Sandra, a local actress, Brosnahan supports an exiled Afghan journalist navigating a dangerous California underworld. The film mixes crime and mystery with a raw, human story.

Her performance brings warmth and grit to a tense narrative. This overlooked thriller offers a fresh take on cultural clashes and personal redemption.

I’m Your Woman (2020)

Brosnahan leads as Jean, a woman on the run after her husband’s criminal betrayal in this 1970s crime drama. Her character’s journey from naive wife to fierce survivor is gripping.

She delivers a bold, emotional performance that anchors the film. It’s a stylish, character-driven story that deserves more love for its unique perspective.

Dead for a Dollar (2022)

In this Western, Brosnahan plays Rachel Kidd, a kidnapped wife whose rescue takes a surprising turn. The film blends action and drama with a twisty plot.

Her role subverts the typical damsel stereotype, showcasing her versatility. It’s a solid pick for Western fans craving something fresh and engaging.

Which of these Rachel Brosnahan films is your favorite, or did we miss a hidden gem you love? Drop your thoughts in the comments!