Timeless Travelers: The Definitive Ranking of All 18 Doctors in ‘Doctor Who’

The Doctor in ‘Doctor Who’ is a galactic icon, zipping through time and space with a new face and flair each regeneration. Every actor brings a distinct vibe, from quirky charm to steely resolve, shaping the show’s epic legacy.

Since 1963, the Time Lord has faced Daleks, Cybermen, and cosmic mysteries, with each Doctor leaving a unique mark. Here are all 18 Doctors from the main TV series, based on their charisma, impact, and storytelling.

‘Doctor Who’ (1983) – First Doctor (Richard Hurndall)

Richard Hurndall stepped in as the First Doctor for the 20th Anniversary Special ‘The Five Doctors.’ His take, filling in for William Hartnell, leans into a gruff, irascible vibe.

Hurndall had the tough task of mimicking another actor, missing the original’s softer side. With limited screen time and a dated feel, he ranks lowest but still holds historical charm.

‘Doctor Who’ (2013-2022) – First Doctor (David Bradley)

David Bradley played the First Doctor in ‘An Adventure in Space and Time’ and later in ‘Twice Upon a Time’ and ‘The Power of The Doctor.’ His fragile, reflective take adds depth.

Bradley’s performance, informed by playing Hartnell, captures the Doctor’s sweeter side, but his brief appearances keep him here. He’s a touching nod to the show’s roots.

‘Doctor Who’ (2020) – Fugitive Doctor (Jo Martin)

Jo Martin’s Fugitive Doctor, revealed in ‘Fugitive of the Judoon,’ is a confident, steely Time Lord from a hidden past. Her swagger sets her apart.

Martin’s brief appearances pack a punch, but limited screen time holds her back. She’s a bold, exciting addition to the lineup.

‘Doctor Who’ (1984-1986) – Sixth Doctor (Colin Baker)

Colin Baker’s Sixth Doctor is loud and brash, with a garish coat and sharp tongue. His abrasive start, including a clash with companion Peri, aimed for a bold anti-hero.

Baker’s talent shines in audio dramas, but weak scripts and a short run hurt his TV era. He’s a Doctor with potential that wasn’t fully realized.

‘Doctor Who’ (1987-1989) – Seventh Doctor (Sylvester McCoy)

Sylvester McCoy’s Seventh Doctor shifts from goofy clown to cunning strategist. His darker turn in the classic series’ final days added intrigue.

McCoy’s charm carries uneven stories, but budget cuts and inconsistent writing limit his impact. He’s a quirky favorite for fans who love his scheming side.

‘Doctor Who’ (1963-1966) – First Doctor (William Hartnell)

William Hartnell’s First Doctor is the original, a cranky grandfather who softens over time. His black-and-white adventures laid the groundwork for the series.

Hartnell’s warmth grows, but slow pacing and dated production values make his era tough to revisit. He’s foundational, yet ranks lower for modern viewers.

‘Doctor Who’ (1970-1974) – Third Doctor (Jon Pertwee)

Jon Pertwee’s Third Doctor is a dashing, gadget-loving hero, often stuck on Earth. His velvet capes and martial arts bring a suave, Bond-like energy.

Pertwee’s charisma shines, but the Earth-bound stories feel limiting. His UNIT teamwork and bold style still resonate with fans.

‘Doctor Who’ (2023-2025) – Fifteenth Doctor (Ncuti Gatwa)

Ncuti Gatwa’s Fifteenth Doctor bursts with vibrant joy and raw emotion, shaking up the TARDIS with his bold, ever-changing style. From kilts to Regency flair, his fluid persona shines through, making him a fresh, unapologetic Time Lord.

His short 18-month run, paired with companions Ruby Sunday and Belinda Chandra, tackles goblins, gods, and the Rani with a mix of heart and flair. Gatwa’s commanding yet vulnerable performance in episodes like ‘Boom’ leaves a big mark, despite some uneven stories.

‘Doctor Who’ (1981-1984) – Fifth Doctor (Peter Davison)

Peter Davison’s Fifth Doctor is a youthful, gentle soul in a cricket outfit. His compassionate nature and crowded TARDIS create heartfelt moments.

Davison’s warmth is a highlight, but inconsistent scripts hold him back. He’s a relatable Doctor who feels like a kind companion.

‘Doctor Who’ (1996) – Eighth Doctor (Paul McGann)

Paul McGann’s Eighth Doctor, seen in the 1996 TV movie, blends romance and mystery. His single TV story limits him, but audio dramas expand his legacy.

McGann’s soulful acting captivates, yet his brief screen time keeps him here. He’s a beloved Doctor for dedicated fans.

‘Doctor Who’ (2013) – War Doctor (John Hurt)

John Hurt’s War Doctor, seen in the 50th anniversary specials, is a battle-scarred hero. His brief role carries immense weight with haunting gravitas.

Hurt makes every moment count, but limited screen time keeps him here. He’s a tragic, powerful Doctor.

‘Doctor Who’ (2018-2022) – Thirteenth Doctor (Jodie Whittaker)

Jodie Whittaker’s Thirteenth Doctor, the first woman in the role, brings warmth and curiosity. Her “fam” of companions and optimistic energy refresh the show.

Whittaker excels, but uneven writing sometimes dims her impact. She’s a historic Doctor who broke new ground.

‘Doctor Who’ (2013-2017) – Twelfth Doctor (Peter Capaldi)

Peter Capaldi’s Twelfth Doctor evolves from gruff loner to warm hero. His rock-star vibe and deep bond with Clara bring emotional weight.

Capaldi’s intense performance lifts complex stories, though early seasons feel heavy. He’s a standout for his growth and depth.

‘Doctor Who’ (2005) – Ninth Doctor (Christopher Eccleston)

Christopher Eccleston’s Ninth Doctor revived the show with gritty intensity. His leather jacket and post-war edge ground the modern era.

Eccleston’s raw emotion shines, but his one-season run limits his rank. He brought the Doctor back with fierce heart.

‘Doctor Who’ (2010-2013) – Eleventh Doctor (Matt Smith)

Matt Smith’s Eleventh Doctor is a quirky, bow-tie-wearing eccentric with youthful charm. His fairy-tale adventures and emotional arcs, like the Ponds’ story, captivate.

Smith’s vibrant range carries complex plots, making him a fan favorite. He’s a lively Doctor who won modern hearts.

‘Doctor Who’ (1966-1969) – Second Doctor (Patrick Troughton)

Patrick Troughton’s Second Doctor is a playful, cosmic hobo with a cunning streak. His recorder and mischievous grin shaped the role’s quirky heart.

Troughton’s charm and influence shine, despite some lost episodes. He’s a pivotal Doctor who defined the character’s core.

‘Doctor Who’ (1974-1981) – Fourth Doctor (Tom Baker)

Tom Baker’s Fourth Doctor, with his long scarf and wild grin, is a cultural icon. His eccentric charm and long run defined the classic era.

Baker’s larger-than-life presence lifts any story, even weaker ones. He’s a legendary Doctor who became the show’s face.

‘Doctor Who’ (2005-2010, 2023) – Tenth & Fourteenth Doctor (David Tennant)

David Tennant’s Tenth Doctor is a charismatic, heartbroken hero with boundless energy. His emotional depth, from Rose’s loss to stories like ‘Blink,’ sets the modern standard.

Tennant’s versatility and charm make him unforgettable, with his Fourteenth Doctor stint adding new layers. He’s the Doctor who stole hearts and defined an era.

Which Doctor’s era is your favorite, or is there a moment that makes one shine? Share your picks in the comments!