LGBTQ+ Stars Who Lost Roles After Coming Out (But Found Success Later)

The journey for LGBTQ+ performers in Hollywood has historically been fraught with professional risks and systemic barriers. For many actors, the decision to live authentically often resulted in the immediate loss of leading roles, canceled contracts, or a sudden lack of opportunities within the major studio system. Despite these significant setbacks, several trailblazing individuals managed to rebuild their careers and find even greater success on their own terms. These stars proved that their talent outweighed the prejudices of the industry, eventually becoming icons of representation and resilience.

Rupert Everett

Everett openly discussed how coming out as gay in the late 1980s negatively impacted his status as a leading man in Hollywood. He stated that he lost out on several major film roles because the industry was not prepared to cast an openly gay actor in heterosexual romantic leads. Despite these setbacks, he earned critical acclaim for his role in ‘My Best Friend’s Wedding’ and found enduring success on the stage. He later transitioned into writing and directing, most notably with the biographical film ‘The Happy Prince’. His career remains a prominent example of the professional risks faced by LGBTQ+ actors in previous decades.

Ellen DeGeneres

In 1997, the eponymous character on the sitcom ‘Ellen’ came out as gay, mirroring the actress’s real-life announcement. Following the disclosure, the show’s ratings declined and it was eventually canceled by the network amidst significant public controversy. DeGeneres struggled to find work for several years as she was considered “too political” for mainstream television. She eventually staged a major comeback by voicing Dory in the film ‘Finding Nemo’ and launching a long-running daytime talk show. Her success paved the way for more LGBTQ+ representation in daytime media.

Matt Bomer

Bomer was reportedly the top choice to play the Man of Steel in a mid-2000s film titled ‘Superman: Flyby’ written by J.J. Abrams. According to the actor, his sexual orientation became a factor in the casting decision, and he was ultimately passed over for the role. Despite this professional setback, he went on to achieve stardom as the lead in the television series ‘White Collar’. He later won a Golden Globe for his performance in ‘The Normal Heart’ and starred in the ‘Magic Mike’ franchise. Bomer has since become one of the most prominent out actors working in both television and film today.

Anne Heche

Heche’s high-profile relationship with Ellen DeGeneres in the late 1990s allegedly led to her being blacklisted by major film studios. She claimed that she was escorted off the Fox lot and lost a multi-picture deal because of her public coming out. The actress faced a significant lull in her film career during what should have been her peak years in Hollywood. She eventually returned to the spotlight with roles in ‘Hung’, ‘Save Me’, and various independent film projects. Their experience remains a frequently cited example of the “lavender ceiling” in the entertainment industry.

Jonathan Bennett

After rising to fame in the hit comedy ‘Mean Girls’, Bennett faced significant pressure to stay in the closet to protect his career. He has since spoken about being outed and subsequently losing out on leading roles because producers felt audiences would not believe him as a romantic interest. For a period, his acting opportunities diminished significantly within the traditional studio system. He eventually found a new career path as a prominent star and producer for the Hallmark Channel, leading their first LGBTQ+ holiday films. Today, he is celebrated as a leading figure in queer-inclusive holiday programming.

T. R. Knight

Knight came out publicly in 2006 following a highly publicized on-set altercation with a co-star on the series ‘Grey’s Anatomy’. He later stated that his decision to live authentically led to a breakdown in communication with the show’s producers and a decrease in his character’s screen time. Feeling that his career was being stifled and his character’s development was stalling, he requested an early release from his contract. Knight successfully transitioned back to theater, earning praise for his work on Broadway and in television series like ‘The Flight Attendant’. He continues to work steadily in character roles across various genres.

Billy Porter

In the 1990s, Porter’s career stalled after he was told by industry executives that his sexual orientation would prevent him from being a mainstream star. He struggled for years to find meaningful work in film and television, often being relegated to minor or stereotypical roles. During this period of professional rejection, he focused on his music and theater career while facing significant financial hardships. He eventually achieved global superstardom with his Tony-winning role in ‘Kinky Boots’ and his Emmy-winning performance in the series ‘Pose’. Porter is now recognized as a fashion icon and a trailblazing force in the entertainment industry.

Please share your thoughts on these incredible career comebacks in the comments.