Top 18 Marvel (MCU) Fan Castings: Some Make Sense, Others Miss the Mark!
Few topics garner as much attention among comic book movie fans as fan castings. Marvel and DC enthusiasts are constantly speculating about which actors would be perfect for the roles of superheroes (and villains) who have yet to grace the big screen or may need a recast.
After collecting fan castings for Marvel and DC roles, we’ve compiled a list of the most intriguing ones. Some are quite promising, while others have sparked controversy among fans.
Keanu Reeves as Ghost Rider
Keanu Reeves is truly known as one of the nicest actors in Hollywood, but he is no stranger to action and supernatural roles. Ever since they saw him in ‘Constantine’ fans have frequently fan-casted ‘The Matrix’ star for the role. Now that there are whispers of a Ghost Rider movie or Midnight Sons-focused project, it might just happen.
Reeves has the brooding and dark personality to definitely pull it off.
Nikolaj Coster-Waldau as Doctor Doom
Nikolaj Coster-Waldau is widely known for his role as Jaime Lannister in the globally acclaimed TV series “Game of Thrones.” Although his time on the show ended with the final season, fans have since envisioned him as Doctor Doom through various fan art and concept trailers. Waldau wouldn’t be the first “Game of Thrones” actor to join the MCU, as both Kit Harington and Richard Madden appeared in “Eternals.”
Waldau has the range and physique to portray the iconic villain. His ability to evoke sympathy makes him an ideal choice for a complex, morally ambiguous character.
Johnny Depp as Mephisto
Mephisto has only been mentioned in the MCU so far, but with the studio’s increasing focus on magic, the Midnight Sons, and similar themes, there’s a strong chance he’ll make his debut soon. Johnny Depp is the most popular fan-casting choice for the role, and now that he’s back in Disney’s good graces, it could actually happen.
Dev Patel as Kang the Conqueror
When Jonathan Majors faced assault allegations from his ex-partner, the studio faced a dilemma: recast Kang or remove him as the villain entirely. Majors’ subsequent guilty verdict and probation only fueled speculation.
Now, it seems the studio is proceeding with Kang, but the character will likely be recast. Fans have suggested Dev Patel for the role. Patel was also considered for the role of Reed Richards in Fantastic Four before Pedro Pascal was cast.
Giancarlo Esposito as Doom
Giancarlo Esposito has risen to prominence as TV’s most iconic villain since his role in ‘Breaking Bad.’ Several months ago, he expressed interest in playing Professor X, only to later reveal that he had been cast in the MCU, but not as Professor X. He also disclosed that his character would have their own MCU series. Given fans’ longstanding speculation about Esposito as a potential Dr. Doom, many are hopeful that this is the role he has been cast in.
Keke Palmer as Rogue
Keke has been a top choice among fans for a particular role for quite some time. With rumors intensifying about the introduction of X-Men into the MCU through a live-action project, it’s not far-fetched to imagine Keke being considered for one of the prominent mutant roles. Keke even acknowledged the fan casting through fan art that depicts her as the mutant character.
Ryan Gosling as Ghost Rider
Ryan Gosling has openly expressed his desire to portray MCU’s Ghost Rider on multiple occasions, and fans eagerly took up the idea. Reports suggest that Gosling has already been cast in a mysterious role within the MCU, and there are also rumors circulating about a Ghost Rider project in development. Several months ago, there were rumors linking Gosling to the role of Nova in an upcoming live-action show.
Sydney Sweeney as Black Cat
Sydney Sweeney has already ventured into the realm of superheroes once, though the outcome wasn’t ideal. Now, fans are eager to see her take on another superpowered role in the MCU, particularly as Felicia Hardy, also known as Black Cat, an anti-hero/villainess and occasional ally of Spider-Man. Recent rumors suggesting Sweeney’s casting in the role have only fueled anticipation.
Henry Cavill as Cyclops
Fans have long speculated about DCEU’s Superman making his way into the MCU. Initially linked with the introduction of Captain Britain, recent buzz, especially following the release of ‘X-Men 97’ and the upcoming ‘X-Men’ MCU reboot, suggests growing interest in Henry Cavill portraying the new Cyclops. Numerous rumors have added to the speculation.
Manny Jacinto as Iron Fist
Manny Jacinto, celebrated for his standout roles in ‘The Good Place’ and ‘The Acolyte,’ has become a fan-favorite choice to play Iron Fist in the MCU. With his impressive martial arts skills, charismatic screen presence, and ability to seamlessly transition between dramatic and comedic roles, Jacinto is seen as the ideal candidate to portray Danny Rand, the Iron Fist.
Miley Cyrus as Rogue
After years of anticipation for quality ‘X-Men’ content, fans were thrilled to receive ‘X-Men 97’! The remake of the beloved 1992 series ‘X-Men: The Animated Series’ was a huge success among Marvel fans. With the excitement surrounding this and the upcoming live-action ‘X-Men’ reboot, fans have been sharing their casting ideas for their favorite mutants. One of the most popular suggestions by far is Miley Cyrus as Rogue. While this casting is unlikely, the mere mention of Miley joining the ‘X-Men’ ranks sparks heated discussions across social platforms!
Josh Holloway as Wolverine
Numerous actors have portrayed iconic superheroes like Batman, Spider-Man, and Superman throughout the years. Yet, one actor stands out above the rest, Hugh Jackman, known for his portrayal of Wolverine since 2000. After two decades, many believed Jackman was finished with the role, only for him to reprise Wolverine in the upcoming ‘Deadpool & Wolverine’—a remarkable 24 years since he first donned the character. A true legend! However, it’s inevitable that we’ll eventually see a new Wolverine, with ‘Lost’s Josh Holloway frequently mentioned as a potential candidate.
Jon Hamm as Mister Sinister
Jon Hamm, renowned for his role in ‘Mad Men,’ is a top fan pick for Mister Sinister. With his ability to portray complex and enigmatic characters, Hamm is seen as a perfect fit for the genetically obsessed villain. Fans are excited to see how his charisma and intensity could bring Mister Sinister to life, potentially making him a standout in the MCU’s ever-expanding roster of antagonists.
Ana de Armas as Mystique
Ana de Armas, known for her dynamic performances in ‘Knives Out’ and ‘No Time to Die,’ is a popular choice to play Mystique. Her versatility and ability to transform into different characters make her an ideal fit for the shape-shifting mutant. Fans are eager to see how de Armas would bring a fresh and compelling interpretation to this iconic role, adding depth and nuance to the beloved character.
Jason Isaacs as Magneto
Jason Isaacs, famous for his roles in ‘Harry Potter’ and ‘The OA,’ is often mentioned by fans as the perfect Magneto. With his commanding presence and ability to portray complex villains, Isaacs could bring a new level of gravitas and intensity to the Master of Magnetism. Fans are excited at the prospect of seeing him lead the Brotherhood of Mutants in the MCU.
Jai Courtney as Sabretooth
Jai Courtney, known for his roles in ‘Suicide Squad’ and ‘Terminator Genisys,’ is a fan favorite for Sabretooth. His physicality and intensity make him a natural fit for the ferocious and brutal adversary of Wolverine. Fans are eager to see Courtney’s take on this iconic villain, hoping he can bring both the menace and depth needed for Sabretooth in the MCU.
Jack Quaid as Multiple Man
Jack Quaid, celebrated for his role in ‘The Boys,’ has been suggested by fans for Multiple Man. With his knack for portraying nuanced and multifaceted characters, Quaid could bring a unique and engaging interpretation to Jamie Madrox. Fans are excited about the potential of seeing Quaid’s charisma and humor shine through in the role of the many-faced mutant.
Mark Strong as Professor X
Mark Strong, known for his commanding screen presence, has been suggested by fans for the role of Professor X. With his ability to convey deep intelligence and authority, Strong could offer a compelling and profound portrayal of Charles Xavier. Fans are enthusiastic about the possibility of seeing Strong’s gravitas and nuanced performance illuminate the character of the cerebral and powerful mutant leader.
Manny Jacinto as Nova
Manny Jacinto, celebrated for his standout role in ‘The Good Place’ and ‘The Acolyte,’ is a top pick among fans to take on the role of Nova in the MCU. Known for his charm, wit, and impressive acting range, Jacinto brings the perfect blend of charisma and depth needed to portray Richard Rider, the human rocket. His dynamic presence on screen and ability to navigate both dramatic and comedic roles make him an exciting choice for Nova, potentially adding a fresh and engaging layer to the MCU’s roster of heroes.
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments below!